This page was last updated on: June 22, 2015
I. STATEMENT OF OBJECTIVESThe Office of the State Comptroller (OSC), on behalf of the State of Connecticut and the Connecticut State Employees Retirement Commission, is soliciting proposals from contractors qualified to serve as Third Party Administrator (TPA) for its 457 plan, 403(b) plan, and Alternate Retirement Program during the period from July 1, 2005 to June 30, 2009. OSC anticipates that during the course of the four-year agreement it seeks to negotiate, the TPA selected will face two over-arching administrative tasks, as follows:
Phase 1. Transitioning the Existing 457(b) plan. Start Date: July 1, 2005. The TPA will be responsible for transitioning participants from the three authorized institutions of the existing 457 Program into its new administrative environment and, working with the Retirement & Benefit Services Division (RBSD) of the OSC and third-party fiduciary advisors, improving the investment offerings. A major objective of this phase will be to introduce lower-priced investment choices and increase the diversity of investment options available to participants. The TPA will be responsible for developing an account transfer communication plan to encourage participant transfers and a mapping strategy for those participants who make no transfer election.
Phase 2. Transitioning the Existing 403(b) plan and Alternate Retirement Program (ARP). Start Date: January 1, 2006. The TPA will be responsible for transitioning participants from the six authorized institutions of the existing 403(b) Plan and the investment choices from a single provider in the existing ARP into its new administrative environment and, working with the RBSD, improving the investment offerings. After January 1, 2006, all new contributions will be invested in the new plan choices. However, unlike the 457 plan, old account balances may not be mappable from the existing providers?participants may need to make elections to transfer existing assets to the new administrative environment. The TPA should develop a strategy to encourage individual participant transfers that minimizes disruption of participant accounts.
In addition to establishing the new administrative environment, the TPA will be responsible for establishing and maintaining a financial education program for participants in all three plans and an IRS compliance program for the 457(b), 403(b) and ARP.II. BACKGROUND INFORMATION
457 Plan
The 457 Program was established in 1974 in accordance with provisions of Public Act No. 73-578 (codified as Connecticut General Statutes, Section 5-264a). Section 5-264a has been revised several times since 1973, but the benefit offered to state employees has not changed substantially. Under Internal Revenue Code, Section 457, state employees can enter into agreements with their employer to defer payment of a defined portion of current compensation until retirement or separation from service. The advantages offered to state employees for participating in the 457 Program include the ability to defer paying income tax on the deferred amount until it is paid or made available to them and, at the same time, serve as a way to save for retirement. As provided by the Connecticut General Statutes, the administration of the 457 Program shall be under the direction of OSC, which is empowered to enter into contracts with state employees to defer earned income and with financial service organizations to provide the necessary investment vehicles. There are currently three such authorized institutions:
The authorized institutions are responsible for explaining the advantages, as well as any disadvantages, to state employees who may be considering participating in the 457 Program. The insurance companies maintain the records of all participants, provide quarterly reporting to each participant, and are the investors of the funds in the 457 Program. Each of the authorized institutions offers a selection of investment possibilities to the participants. Although OSC is responsible for "due care" in selecting the providers approving the investment vehicles, the participants assume the risk of any loss from decreases in the values of the 457 Program's assets. Since the TPA will assume all responsibilities currently assumed by the current insurance company vendors, their contracts with OSC will be terminated as of June 30, 2005.
As allowed under the Connecticut General Statutes, OSC is under contract with Mellon HR as a limited scope TPA. Mellon has been compensated under agreements it negotiates with the authorized institutions of the 457 Program. OSC anticipates that Mellon's responsibilities will be assumed by the TPA and, for this reason, the limited scope TPA agreement will be also be terminated.
Currently, approximately 26,000 participants with over $950 million in assets contribute to the 457 plan. Estimated annual contributions exceed $90 million.
Alternate Retirement Program
The Alternate Retirement Program (ARP) was established by P.A. 75-636 in 1975 and enrollment in the plan began in 1976. Since its inception, TIAA-CREF has been the sole financial services organization for the plan. The ARP qualifies under section 401(a) of the Internal Revenue Code. The State of Connecticut contributes 8% of pay to the plan and participants pay 5%.
As a general proposition, unclassified employees of the following state agencies are eligible to participate in the ARP: (1) University of Connecticut, including the University of Connecticut Health Center; (2) State Universities, including the Board of Trustees; (3) Community-Technical Colleges, including the Board of Trustees; (4) Department of Higher Education central office staff. At the current time, approximately 8,500 employees are actively contributing to the ARP. The Plan has approximately $1 billion in assets, with over $24 million in employee contributions and $38 million in employer contributions added annually.
Until July, 1992, the ARP was funded with individual retirement annuity contracts with TIAA-CREF. Since July, 1992, the ARP has been funded with TIAA-CREF group retirement annuity contracts.
403(b) Plan
The 403(b) Program is an employer-sponsored, tax-sheltered retirement supplement, similar to the Connecticut Deferred Compensation (457) Plan. However, unlike the 457 Plan, which is open to all employees, the 403(b) Program is available only to state educational employees. As a general proposition, employees of the following state agencies are eligible to participate in the 403(b) Program: (1) University of Connecticut, including the University of Connecticut Health Center; (2) State Universities, including the Board of Trustees; (3) Community-Technical Colleges, including the Board of Trustees; (4) Department of Higher Education; (5) Department of Education, including the Vocational-Technical High Schools; (6) Department of Correction, Unified School District No.1; (7) Department of Children and Families, Unified School District No. 2; and, (8) Department of Mental Retardation, Unified School District No. 3. At the current time, approximately 5,600 employees are actively contributing to the 403(b) Program.
Recognizing the 403(b) Program to be in need of reform and modernization, the General Assembly transferred responsibility for its management to the Office of the State Comptroller (OSC). At the time of transfer of authority, sixty-six vendors participated in the 403(b) Program. Consistent with this grant of legislative authority, OSC pursued a number of improvements in the 403(b) Program, including the competitive selection of six authorized Financial Services Organizations (FSOs). The following six FSOs were chosen effective July, 2002:
Fidelity Investments | Oldham Resource Group |
The Hartford | TIAA-CREF |
ING | Travelers Life & Annuity |
Currently, 5,600 participants with approximately $400 million in assets actively contribute to the 403(b) plan. Annual employee contributions equal about $40 million.
Information about all three plans is available at: www.osc.state.ct.us/empret/ .
III. DISCUSSION
The State is interested in replacing the current administrative structure with a TPA arrangement. The goal is to establish a centrally-administered, institutionally-priced platform that will enable the state to offer improved services and investment offerings to participants at a substantially lower price.
Under the current arrangement, financial education seminars and other meetings with participants have been difficult to arrange due to the multi-vendor environment. In addition, IRS compliance problems have existed. In particular, contribution and catch-up limits have been difficult to track with multiple vendors.
For the 457 plan transition, all new contributions after July 1, 2005 will be made to investment options on the new platform. Participants will be given sufficient time to choose new investment options. Participants who do not make an election will be mapped to similar funds on the new platform. Contractors should discuss in their proposal how they would propose transitioning participants in the existing guaranteed fixed accounts of ING, The Hartford, and Phoenix.
For the 403(b) and ARP transitions, all new contributions after January 1, 2006, will be made to the investment options on the new platform. Since participants will have considerable lead-time to select new investment choices, it is anticipated that most participants will have made selections by January 1, 2006. However, unlike the 457 plan, new contributions and existing assets cannot be mapped to the new platform. Contractors should discuss how they propose to work with the state to ensure that participants transfer accounts to the new platform.
Proposed Changes
The goals for the new plan design are to offer more and better investment choices, lower fees, central administration, third-party fiduciary advice, improved counseling and other services to participants, and greater fee transparency and accountability to the state.
Minimum Qualifications
In order to be considered, each contractor responding to this RFP must, at a minimum, possess the following qualifications:
A. Organizational ExperienceThe contractor must have been in operation for at least five continuous years as of December 31, 2004.
B. Professional ExperienceThe chief administrative officer and account representatives of the TPA must each have at least a three-year history of providing administrative services for Section 457, Section 401(a), 401(k), or Section 403(b) plans as of December 31, 2004.
C. Plans Under AdministrationThe contractor must have a minimum of five (5) Section 457, Section 401(a) defined contribution, or Section 403(b) plans, each with at least 5,000 participants, to which it provides administrative services as of December 31, 2004.
November 23, 2004 | Release of RFP by OSC |
December 10, 2004 | Letters of Intent with contractor email address due at RBSD of the OSC |
December 14, 2004 | Questions due at osc.dcplans@po.state.ct.us |
December 17, 2004 | OSC answers questions received via email to all contractors |
January 14, 2005 | Proposals due at RBSD of the OSC |
Review and Selection Schedule
January 15-February 1, 2005 | Reading and Scoring of Proposals by Screening Committee | |
February 1 - 15, 2005 | Finalist Interviews | see note 1 |
March 1, 2005 | TPA Selection | see note 2 |
March 2- 31, 2005 | Contract Negotiations | |
July 1, 2005 | TPA Conversion | see note 3 |
Notes:
RIGHTS RESERVED TO OSC
OSC reserves the right to award in part, to reject any and all proposals in
whole or in part, to waive technical defects, irregularities and omissions if,
in its judgement, the best interest of the State will be served.
INSTRUCTIONS TO CONTRACTORS
Conformance - All responses to this RFP must conform to these instructions. Failure to conform may be considered appropriate cause for rejection of the response.
Communication Blackout Period - Except as called for in this RFP, contractors may not communicate with the OSC, the Retirement & Benefit Services Division of the OSC, or members of the State Employees Retirement Commission about the RFP until a TPA is selected.
Letter of Intent - The letter of intent will be due at the offices of the RBSD by 4:30 PM on December 10, 2004. In the letter, the Contractor must provide an email address for communication of information about the RFP, answers to questions submitted by contractors, and other matters about the contractor selection process.
Delivery of Responses - RFP responses must be in sealed envelopes upon which a clear indication has been made of the RFP reference title, as well as the date and time the proposal is due. The name and address of the contractor must appear on the envelope. FAX responses are not acceptable.
Structure of Response - Contractors must structure the responses as outlined in this RFP.
Exclusion of Taxes from Prices - The State of Connecticut is exempt from the payment of excise, transportation, and sales taxes imposed by the Federal Government and the State. Such taxes must be excluded from quoted prices.
Prohibition of Commissions - The State of Connecticut will contract directly with organizations capable of performing the requirements of this RFP. Contractors must be represented directly. Participation by brokers or commissioned agents will not be allowed during the proposal process or during the term of the proposed contract between the TPA and the State. The selected TPA will submit a compensation plan for TPA personnel for approval by the OSC and may not include broker or commissioned agent fees either implicit or explicit in the costs of the TPA contract. The approved plan will be included in the contract between the State and the TPA.
Signature and Responsible Persons - The proposal must be signed by an authorized official. The proposal must also provide name, title, address, and telephone number for individuals with authority to negotiate and contractually bind the contractor, and for those who may be contacted for the purpose of clarifying the information provided.
"Not to Exceed" Quotations - All cost estimates will be considered as "not to exceed" quotations.
TERMS AND CONDITIONS
Any contractor responding to this RFP must be willing to adhere to the following conditions and must so state in its submission:
IV. PROPOSAL SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS
1. The Contractor shall submit an original plus nine (9) copies of its proposal in loose-leaf binders. Proposals shall be submitted to:STATE OF CONNECTICUT
Office of the State Comptroller
Attention: Thomas C. Woodruff, Ph.D.
Director
Retirement & Benefit Services Division
55 Elm Street
Hartford, CT 06106
3. Proposal should include the following:
The title page should indicate the date, subject, name of the contractor, address, telephone number, name and title of contractor's contact person.
A description of the office that would support the State's activities, including its geographic location, staffing level, the background, experience, and qualifications of personnel, as well as other available resources.
A description of your experience specific to the services requested in this RFP. List all other government agencies, Corporations, and Organizations that you have provided these services for in the past two (2) years. The profile should not exceed four (4) pages.
Complete answers to "Request for Proposal" Section VI.
Samples of reports, policy and procedural recommendations, memoranda, etc., from previous consulting engagements relevant to the scope of work proposed in this contract may be attached to the proposal. It is only necessary to submit one copy of each sample for consideration.
The contractor will submit a detailed line item budget with narrative for each of the three (3) years. The budget should include all personnel and non-personnel costs associated with the implementation and ongoing operations under this contract.
The State of Connecticut is not responsible for any costs incurred by any party in responding to this RFP.
The Proposal must include a summary of the contractor's experience with Affirmative Action. This information is to include a summary of the contractor's affirmative action plan and the contractor's affirmative action policy statement. Regulations of Connecticut State Agencies Section 46a-68j-30(10) requires agencies to consider the following factors when awarding a contract that is subject to contract compliance requirements:
A "Notification to Contractors" form is attached, which should be read and signed by the contractor. (Attachment I)
Also attached is a Contract Compliance Requirement reporting form, which the contractor must complete and sign, which will be sent to the Commission on Human Rights and Opportunities by the awarding agency. (Attachment II)
At the contractor's option, an Executive Summary may be included in the Proposal.
V. EVALUATION OF PROPOSALSEach proposal will be evaluated by a Screening Committee using the following criteria to determine which contractor is most capable of implementing OSC's requirements, as follows:
VI. REQUEST FOR PROPOSAL QUESTIONNAIRE
ORGANIZATION AND HISTORY
Number of Employees in Plans | Total Number Defined Contribution Plans |
---|---|
Under 100 | |
100-499 | |
500-999 | |
1,000-4,999 | |
Over 5,000 | |
Total |
Plan Assets (M = Millions) | Total Number of Defined Contribution Plans |
---|---|
Under $10M | |
From $10M to $50M | |
From $50M to $100M | |
From $100M to $250M | |
Over $250M |
10. Please provide a breakdown of the number of clients you service by plan type as a percentage of your total business:
Plan Type - Percentage of Total Business | |||
---|---|---|---|
Plan Type | Full Service | Investment Only | Administration Only |
401(a) | |||
401(k) | |||
403(b) Governmental | |||
403(b) Non-Governmental | |||
457(b) Governmental | |||
457(b)Non-Governmental | |||
Other | |||
Total |
11. Please provide your most recent audited financial statement. If the proposing firm is an insurance company please provide your claims paying ability ratings from
12. Describe any litigation, past or pending, against your organization or on-site service representatives resulting from your current or past involvement with any deferred compensation, defined contribution or public/private pension plan in the past five years.
13. Has your organization or have your service representatives been cited, or reprimanded by any regulatory agency within the past ten years? If so, please describe.
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE / CORPORATE RESPONSIBILITY
CLIENT SERVICE / QUALITY ASSURANCE
Functional Area | All Plans | 403(b) & 457(b) Plans |
---|---|---|
Financial Record keeping | ||
Plan Administration | ||
Client Service | ||
Technology | ||
Plan Conversion/Installation | ||
Total |
RECORD-KEEPING / ADMINISTRATION
REPORTING
VOICE RESPONSE SYSTEM (VRS), INTERNET ACCESS AND CALL CENTER
Voice Response System (VRS)
Internet Access
Call Center
COMMUNICATION AND EDUCATION
Number of group meetings (minimum of 100) |
|
Number of individual meetings (minimum of 500) |
|
Total number of service hours |
|
Subjects to be covered |
CONVERSION PROCESS
REGULATORY SERVICES
1. Describe in detail how your organization will monitor, cap and/or resolve the following maximum contribution limits for 403(b)/457 participants.
2. What "safeguards" are built into your system to prevent over deferrals from all Plans? How are over deferrals handled? How do you address violations for any of the testing covered in question 1?
3. What fiduciary responsibility does your organization assume?
4. How do you ensure that your record-keeping system is in compliance with all pertinent laws and regulations?
5. How do you keep plan sponsors informed and updated on any regulatory and legislative changes affecting 457(b) , 401(a), and 403(b) plans?
SYSTEMS CAPABILITIES AND HARDWARE
1. Describe the hardware platform and software system you use to recordkeep and administer defined contribution plans.
2. Was the software developed internally, leased, or bought from another provider? Who has the ultimate responsibility to make sure the software is updated to reflect changes in the laws, regulations, client needs, etc.?
3. How often is the system upgraded?
4. Describe the system enhancements you have planned over the next three years for:
5. Describe your documented disaster recovery plan. How often do you test your recovery system?
6. Describe your maintenance and backup procedures including daily backups, retention timetable and off site backup storage approach. Where are your off-site backup facilities located? Are backup records stored in two separate locations.
7. Describe the method of maintaining plan sponsor and participant history on the system and the period such information is maintained.
8. Describe the valuation methods offered by your system.
9. Are internal controls of your recordkeeping system audited by an independent accounting firm on an annual or more frequent basis? If so, please describe such controls and provide a copy of the most recent report.
10. How do you control access to the recordkeeping system? What security precautions are in place?
11. Does the system allow for plan sponsor customization/limits such as:
12. Describe your system's maximum limits with regard to the following:
13. Please provide ongoing transaction layouts if specific layouts are required.
14. Do you provide software that enables plan sponsors to interact with your system? If so, please describe its capabilities and optimal user system requirements.
INVESTMENTS
1. How long have you been providing investment services?
2. Please identify the names by type for all investment vehicles you are proposing.
3. What is the maximum number of investment options that can be handled by your system?
4. In addition to the funds you are proposing, please provide an entire list of the funds available through your proprietary and alliance networks.
5. Please disclose all revenue sharing agreements you have in place with the funds that you are proposing. Note: 12b-1 fees will not be permitted.
6. For each investment vehicle you are proposing, Complete as Exhibit I the following:
7. For each investment vehicle, provide the 1-year annualized return, and the 3-, 5- and 10-year (or since inception) annualized returns, risk-adjusted returns and annualized standard deviations ending on the last calendar quarter.
8. For any guaranteed return investment, including fixed annuity accounts, describe the current and minimum interest rate guarantees, how interest is credited, and the frequency of rate changes. If interest is credited by vintage or "bucket," how many "buckets" can exist in a participant's account?
9. For a money market investment vehicle, provide the 7-day current yield as of the last three calendar quarter-end dates.10. Do you offer a brokerage window for participants in 403(b), 457, and 401(a) defined contribution plans? If so, provide a full description. Describe all fees, mutual funds available, and the ability of plan sponsors to determine which mutual funds are available to participants through the window.
11. Do you provide prospectuses to participants following their initial investments in funds? Please provide a prospectus for each fund proposed.
REFERENCES
MISCELLANEOUS
1. Please provide any additional information you feel may be relevant in evaluating your proposal.
COST PROPOSAL
Please describe your cost proposal and approach towards fees. Please describe your approach to revenue sharing.
SAMPLE PLAN ADMINISTRATION BUDGET
Please Construct a Sample budget for the first three years of plan operations. Assume 457(b) plan implementation July 1, 2005 and 403(b) and ARP implementation on January 1, 2006. The purpose of the sample budget is to demonstrate that your company can provide the necessary plan services within the budget that will be possible from revenue from plan administration fees.